Cabaye challenges Kinnear to come clean on Cabayegate (the full exchange translated)
Posted on October 8th, 2013 | 79 Comments |
In an interview as part of the France squad at the side’s Clairefontaine HQ, Cabaye made some rather suggestive comments about what Alan Pardew called “the situation” at the time. If you recall, Pardew made a series of simlarly suggestive statements, implying that Cabaye refused to play in early season games in order to allegedly force a move to Arsenal. However, he steadfastly refused to mention it outright under the pathetic pretence that he was “protecting” Cabaye, even though he was actually hanging him out to dry with innuendo. When interviewers did ask for a direct answer, interviews were quickly halted by a female press secretary and they quickly got the message.
However, the fleet-footed Frenchman has now cast doubt on the Pardew’s and the club’s narrative, suggesting that only he and Joe Kinnear know the truth of what really happened, challenging Kinnear to play “Deep Throat” and finally come clean on what really happened in the ‘Cabayegate’ scandal.
Below is the full exchange about Cabaye and the Newcastle United imbroglio (translated by myself):
Interviewer: “The Newcastle United fans whistled at you on you return to the team. Do you understand?”
Cabaye: (Pauses) “The State of mind of the supporters was born from what the club wanted. As I have said, I didn’t explain what happened, they attacked. This is part of a career. But I don’t want anyone. No problems. I accept it.”
Interviewer: “Why won’t you explain what has happened with Newcastle?”
Cabaye: “Because it’s in the past. The only person who could explain everything is Joe Kinnear. If he is honest, he will say. Otherwise, it won’t come out of my mouth.”
As I have explained in previous pieces, it could be that Cabaye has a confidentiality clause in his contract which forbids him from saying anything about it. But getting back to the interview:
Interviewer: “Mentally, has your aborted transfer to Arsenal been hard to swallow?”
Cabaye: “At the time, Yes. But I quickly recovered because if you think about it, if you want a lot of people, it is pointless. I quickly got out of that and went back to work.”
Interviewer: “Have you lost time over the past year between your injuries and the problems at Newcastle?”
Cabaye: “Even if the seasons are not as we wish, we always learn. There are things that could be done better in the future. Last season will serve me.”
As I mentioned above, the club never actually came out themselves on what really happened, relying on innuendo, not to mention friendly journalists such as Lee Ryder in the local media (who was more direct in his accusations) to guide the thinking of we fans in the direction they wanted, ie to vilify Cabaye for his disloyalty, rather than the club for hawking him around like a piece of livestock at a cattle market.
Could it be that the club blackmailed Cabaye, forcing him to to keep his mouth shut using the terms of his contract, his place in the France team, or a promise of co-operation in a January move?
Or could it be that when Cabaye said he “quickly got out of that and went back to work” it was an oblique confession that he did indeed refuse to play at one stage?
Alas, it’s still as clear as mud, the only thing being certain is that like many other things which have happened under Ashley at Newcastle United, there is still far more to this than meets the eye.
What do you think? Please vote in our latest poll, and/or leave your thoughts below.
Poll

it all smells awfully fishy.