Alan Pardew’s St James’ Park Fortress?
Posted on October 14th, 2011 | 60 Comments |
Has St James Park started to become a ‘fortress’ since Alan Pardew took the managerial reigns, starting from his first match against Liverpool on the 11th of December 2010?
If we cast our minds back to the 2009 – 2010 Championship winning season under Chris Hughton, Newcastle managed to complete the season without loss at St James’ Park. In fact, Newcastle only suffered four defeats in the league that entire campaign. I remember Newcastle having a reasonably easy ride at home that season, largely due to the quality of squad we possessed in comparison to the rest of the league, though I do recall West Brom giving us a scare, in our 2-2 draw towards the latter stages of the season.
Newcastle’s first match at home in the Premier League the following season, consisted of a 6-0 thumping of Aston Villa. With United seemingly continuing their fantastic home form, you would have been forgiven for thinking Newcastle would ease past their next home opponents, Blackpool, and extend their unbeaten home run on Tyneside to an impressive 26 games in all competitions.
Well, as we all know, Blackpool prospered on the day 2-0 thanks to goals from Charlie Adam and DJ Campbell. Obviously the defeat came as a shock, and if anything, should have served as a wake up call. Things in the Premier League are vastly different to the Championship, and it wasn’t going to be the nice easy ride we endured at home in the previous season. Our Next adversary was to be Stoke City, surely United would learn from their mistakes and not underestimate their opponents?
Again, Newcastle lost, this time 2-1 after leading 1-0 at half time thanks to a Kevin Nolan penalty. Our next home league fixture was a lucky escape against Wigan, where we found ourselves 2-0 down, only for a stoppage time equaliser from the head of Fabricio Coloccini, to rescue United a point. A 4-0 League Cup defeat by Arsenal was then followed by the 5-1 demolition of the Mackems. But again we came crashing back down to Earth, as Sam Allardyce led his Blackburn side to a 2-1 victory in front of the Toon Army. Fulham were the next visitors, playing out to a 0-0 draw. Chelsea proved to be the last opponents at St James’ Park for Newcastle under the management of Chris Hughton, with the match ending in a 1-1 draw.
Enter Alan Pardew…
Pardew’s first game in charge for Newcastle, was the 3-1 victory at home to Liverpool. Next, was the 3-1 defeat inflicted by Manchester City. Leon Best grabbed a hat-trick as United smashed West Ham 5-0, and then Aaron Lennon rescued a point for Spurs during stoppage time, in our 1-1 draw in January. The next home encounter was the epic 4-4 draw with Arsenal, which was then followed by a share of the spoils against Bolton Wanderers. Everton were then victorious at St James’ Park, winning 2-1, but United responded by thumping their next opponents, Wolves, 4-1. Newcastle wrapped up their home league fixtures with a stalemate versus eventual champions Manchester United, a 2-1 victory over Birmingham City and a ridiculous 3-3 draw with West Brom on the final day of the season. This season at St James’ Park, Newcastle have held Arsenal to a 0-0 draw, beaten Fulham 2-1 and beaten Blackburn 3-1.
Under Chris Hughton, Newcastle had some fantastic results at home during the Premier Leagues 2010 – 2011 season, notably the 6-0 against Villa and the 5-1 Versus the tramps. Obviously we had some cracking results away from home under Hughton too, but I only want to focus on our home record at present. Of course, there were however some poor results, losing at home to the likes of Blackpool, Stoke and Blackburn, which were at the time, a big cause for concern. Under Alan Pardew, Newcastle’s home form improved, especially against the teams that were ‘on our level’, though Newcastle did suffer defeats to Everton and Manchester City, Everton remain the only team outside last seasons top six clubs to have defeated Newcastle at St James’ Park under Pardew.
I think Newcastle certainly have improved at home under Pardew, hence why I have written above our results from 2010 to now, so you can analyze the results yourselves and come to your own conclusions. Pardew’s home record since his appointment as manager stands at P14 W6 D6 L2 (including cup competitions), and if you consider Newcastle have faced Arsenal (twice), Man Utd, Man City, Liverpool and Tottenham in that sequence, I think it’s a pretty good record. Hughton’s home record from the 2010 -2011 season (including cup competitions) was P9 W2 D3 L4. In that sequence, the ‘top’ clubs we faced were Arsenal (League Cup) and Chelsea.
Some of you will undoubtedly state that I shouldn’t count the 3-1 victory against Liverpool for Pardew, and that should count as Hughton’s victory. Well as records show, Pardew was the manager.
So what do you think, if you read the above and take in consideration Newcastle’s home record since Pardew’s arrival? If anything, what has improved and how has it been improved? Has it been luck? Or has Pardew installed something we were missing at the start of the 2010 – 2011 season?
Discuss.
1st?